Back to the YouTube creator guide

Creator workflow guide

AI Tools for YouTube Shorts: 3 Tested

We tried three free browser tools on the same 66-second landscape video. This comparison shows which tools picked a clip for us, how much control we had over the vertical crop, and what came out of the export.

Tested in Chromium on

What each tool did with the same video

The 640 × 360 test clip used synthetic English narration and a marker that moved from center to right to left. We checked the tools for trimming, vertical framing, captions, and whether a free MP4 could be saved. The sample had no faces, so judge face tracking on your own footage.

Automatic clip suggestions and editable captions

Cutlia

Cutlia suggested one section from about 0:01 to 0:33. After its automatic cuts, the downloaded MP4 ran 22.1 seconds at 720 × 1280. We saw burned-in captions and no brand watermark in the frames we checked. Around 0:18 in the export, the right-side marker was largely cropped out. Try its Whole picture framing when important details move across the source frame.

Free access. We downloaded the clip without an account or payment. The optional download for AI-written titles and clip picks was separate from the workflow we tested.

Official product information

Full timeline with a 1080p export

Cutmallow

Using the default export settings, Cutmallow saved the full sample as a 66.1-second, 1080 × 1920 MP4. The blurred background kept the off-center marker in view. We saw no brand watermark in the frames we checked. Caption generation still needed the first-run model when we exported, so this file had no captions.

Free access. The download required neither an account nor payment. The editor accepts MP4, MOV, and WebM files up to 15 minutes, according to its file picker.

Official product information

Manual trimming and framing

Convert to Shorts

We used Blur letterbox and the Medium quality setting. The 66-second MP4 kept the off-center marker visible, and we saw no brand watermark in the frames we checked. The exported file measured 720 × 1280 even though the editor listed 1080 × 1920. We exported with captions off after the model download delayed caption generation.

Free access. We saved the Medium export without an account or payment. The provider lists a 10-minute and 1080p limit for source files.

Official product information

Which workflow fits your footage?

Start with Cutlia if you want a suggested clip and editable captions. Give the framing a second look if someone or something moves toward the edge. Pick Cutmallow for a timeline and a verified 1080p portrait export. Use Convert to Shorts when you already know what to cut and want a simpler crop control.

What should you check before uploading?

Play the exported MP4 on a phone. Check whether the opening line makes sense on its own, whether a subject near the edge survives the crop, and whether captions match names and numbers. Keep the wide original so you can try a different crop without re-encoding the export.